Series 3

Andy Simpkins · Post by **Andy Simpkins** » Tue May 15, 2007 7:23 pm

Well, the face of the Serbian entry certainly scared me.......

macfadyan · Post by **macfadyan** » Sat May 26, 2007 7:50 pm

no remarks about 42 it seems? interesting..

however, Human Nature...brilliant?

'Absolutely'

Post by **Adam J Purcell** » Sat May 26, 2007 8:01 pm

42 - it was okay but it lacked a real sense of jeopardy that the script was so clearly trying to go for. A forgettable episode for me.

Human Nature... Hmmm. I hate to comment on part ones without seeing the conclusion but... I thought it was deadly dull, I'm afraid. Looking at Digital Spy everyone appears to completely disagree with me, it looks like it has the highest ratings so far. Nice productions values but, well, I just don't care about this John Smith's love life. Why should I or any other Doctor Who viewer? Get on with the damned story!

lordsummerisle · Post by **lordsummerisle** » Sun May 27, 2007 6:57 am

I heard somewhere that Doctor Who was being described as "Eastenders: Lost In Space"

I agree that 42 was pretty forgettable but Human Nature is the best of the series so far even if the competition has been less than impressive.

I think Paul must have been raiding old DC Comics for plots though ... if I had a pound for every time Superman, the JLA or the Legion Of Superheroes hid from some deadly enemy in the past with their minds cloaked. That's not intended to take anything away from it though, on one level it's the most 'traditional' looking Doctor Who story of the revived series.

Hobbit · Post by **Hobbit** » Sun May 27, 2007 7:35 pm

Enjoyed it - knew I would - and the music was excellent.

macfadyan · Post by **macfadyan** » Sun May 27, 2007 11:03 pm

Thanks, Hobbit....I enjoyed putting our pilot podcast together, though I may disagree with you about the music....um..you were talking about our podcast, weren't you????

lordsummerisle · Post by **lordsummerisle** » Sat Jun 02, 2007 7:24 pm

A pretty decent conclusion to the story from Mr. Cornell there, even if it did get all a bit Sapphire & Steel towards the end. Adds a touch of mystery once again to the Doctor's character, and for the first time in ages, some effective menace too. I suspect the more touchy-feely aspects of it are down to Russel T so I'm even willing to forgive its occasional straying into the land of angst.

Unlike the Dalek two-parter, the second part didn't disappoint. I'll even go so far as to say it could almost have warranted a third episode without looking too padded. The best of this series so far, by quite a way!

lordsummerisle · Post by **lordsummerisle** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 12:10 pm

lordsummerisle wrote:The best of this series so far, by quite a way!

That status only lasted a week though. "Blink" was superb! Seems like they've saved the best stories until the end of the series.

Andy Simpkins · Post by **Andy Simpkins** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 9:24 pm

I totally agree.'Blink' was a very atmospheric and sinister episode.However, I think they were having a dig at'Primeval'.In the closing scenes where Sally Sparrow is looking out of theDVD shop window and sees The Doctor and Martha getting out the car and she runs after them.The Doctor says there are 'four of them...... and a big lizard...' which could explain everyones favourite tranked-up professor; Nick Cutter,his cohorts and Rex the flying lizard.

Hobbit · Post by **Hobbit** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 10:30 pm

Favourite line: "It's my timey-wimey detector. It goes beep when there's stuff'

Staggering Stories Feeds:

Series 3