Page 1 of 1

The New Assistant

Posted: Wed Jul 05, 2006 5:16 pm
by lordsummerisle
http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/classic/ ... ge30.shtml

I'm joking of course.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/5146666.stm

Best of luck to the new gal, though of course she'll never be as good as the last one, who wasn't as good as the one before that, and they weren't as good as the one before, and she was nowhere near as good as the one before her ...... <snip> .... who as never as good as Susan.

Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2006 12:32 pm
by Adam J Purcell
Disappointing they didn't go with that first link of yours - she would have made a brill companion on the new series! :twisted:

We'll have to wait and see with this new companion, very hard to judge from those couple of scenes last week. 'Martha' though?! Can't say I was very taken with the name 'Rose' initially but that quickly changed. Martha, though? Very odd name, can't help but think of Superman's mummy!! :)

Any bets from when and where she will come from? Modern day London (or Cardiff given the name 'Jones')? Will she even be human? More importantly, will she have an idiot boyfriend and mother who turn up every other story?

Overall I'm quite hopeful about her. She's a virtual unknown, so clearly wasn't cast because of who she is rather than what she can do (as people feared about Billie). On the other hand Matthew Waterhouse was something of an unknown before he was cast..! I think in this case it is probably fair to say the executive producer didn't have any casting couch for Freema, though!

These secret auditions with Tennant will hopefully ensure they will work well together on screen. Clearly Billie was cast with Eccleston in mind, not Tennant, so with luck we'll have a bit more decent Martha and 10th Doctor interaction than we've had with Rose and 10. Looking back on the seasons it certainly seems to me that Rose and 9 had more decent scenes together than we've had this season. I'm not suggesting there was any problem between Tennant and Piper (in fact I get the feeling she much preferred working with Tennant than Eccleston but that could be my imagination coloured by Eccleston's apparent unhappiness with the part.) But I'm drifting... I will not clown...

Anyway, optimistic but cautious. They did a good job with casting Billie last time, let's hope they've still got it. Potentially this could be more upsetting for the new fanbase (the apparent huge under 16 female contingent in particular) than the regeneration.

Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2006 3:57 pm
by lordsummerisle
I'd hope we can get away from the mum and idiot boyfriend scenario too, otherwise she'll just be a regenerated Rose rather than a character in her own right. Hopefully we'll be seeing less of a certain Walfordesque South London housing estate too, but yes, Cardiff seems a good bet at the moment.

But who can say, at the moment we know nothing of her character other than her name.